Could This Comeback Club Be The Best Player's Distance Iron Of 2025?

Irons tester Joe Ferguson has been looking at the first iron release from Maxfli in over 30 years…

Photo of the Maxfli XC2 Irons
(Image credit: Future)
Golf Monthly Verdict

As comebacks go, this is pretty exceptional. The XC2 is one of the best-looking irons in the compact distance category, and the soft forged feel offers something a little different to many of its competitors. This iron stacks up in terms of performance, too, with some strong distance output.

Reasons to buy
  • +

    Exceptional looks

  • +

    Soft forged feel

  • +

    Competitive distance output

Reasons to avoid
  • -

    Shorter irons aren’t my favorite profile behind the ball

Why you can trust Golf Monthly Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.

Where have you been, Maxfli?! This once great equipment brand inexplicably disappeared off the mainstream radar in the early 2000s, and many of us thought that was it! However, there were some signs of life when it was announced that Lexi Thompson would be putting a Maxfli ball into play, and subsequently, PGA Tour winner Ben Griffin has done the same. Then, lo and behold, there were some rumours and brief sightings of some clubs in the works…

Photo of the Maxfli XC2 Irons

(Image credit: Future)

I am delighted to say that I have been sent a set of the new Maxfli XC2 irons and have been putting them through their paces to see if this comeback iron can rival some of the best irons on the market.

Starting with the tech and what we are looking at with the XC2 is very much a forged cavity back, but the forging process is an interesting one here. They are actually forged five times, and in the midst of that process, the designers left some small pockets in the head to fill with tungsten in the toe and ceramic in the heel in order to enhance forgiveness and balance out the CG placement.

Photo of the Maxfli XC2 Irons

(Image credit: Future)

A radiused sole has been used, and there is significant leading edge relief designed to promote a slippery turf interaction at impact.

Looks-wise, I find it difficult to imagine a better-looking iron in this category, and the response I got to a post I put on social media when I received them would certainly corroborate that. The brushed matt finish is fantastic, offering a really premium feel, and something about the Maxfli logo just looks great! A few people in the comments on social media noted the striking resemblance to the Ping i230 iron, which I can definitely see too.

Photo of the Maxfli XC2 Irons face

(Image credit: Future)

In terms of the playing position profiles, on the whole, they are good, although the shorter irons are a touch more angular than I ordinarily like. The mid to long irons, however, are beautifully shaped with good proportions and frame the ball well.

Photo of the Maxfli XC2 Irons address profile

(Image credit: Future)

In terms of performance, I am happy to say I was not disappointed. Whatever wizardry the designers employed with the multiple forging and ceramic inserts has absolutely paid off; they feel fantastic. I am so used to feeling that hot, springy sensation in this category of iron (as the bulk of them are hollow-bodied), that feeling a much more subtle and soft impact was extremely refreshing.

Interestingly, on the whole, that softer feel didn’t compromise the ball speed and distance output too much, and they performed well in that regard. I decided to pit them against what I still believe to be the category leader for compact distance irons, the TaylorMade P790, and was pleasantly surprised.

In terms of the 7-iron data, there was less than 2 mph of ball speed difference between the two and only 5 yards of carry for me, albeit in favour of the TaylorMade model, although the very slight difference in loft could account for some of that. The Maxfli XC2 7-iron is 30.5˚, while the P790 is 30˚.

As I went through the bag, these distance differences jumped around a little with the Maxfli producing stronger results in the shorter irons the the TaylorMade P790, and this was the opposite way round as I moved up into the 4-iron, for example, with the P790 significantly outhitting the XC2. Once again, though, I would put the majority of that down to the loft discrepancies between the sets at various points, which is certainly something to take note of if you are considering a purchase.

I had very high hopes for these irons based purely on nostalgia and the initial looks, and thankfully, they did not disappoint me. What I love the most is that they offer a genuine alternative in terms of feel to most of the compact distance category while not compromising on the performance characteristics of speed and distance that people shopping in this area are looking for.

The Maxfli XC2 irons are priced at $999.00 for a 4-PW set.

Joe Ferguson
Staff Writer

Joe has worked in the golf industry for nearly 20 years in a variety of roles. After a successful amateur career being involved in England squads at every age group, Joe completed his PGA degree qualification in 2014 as one of the top ten graduates in his training year and subsequently went on to become Head PGA Professional at Ryder Cup venue The Celtic Manor Resort. Equipment has always been a huge passion of Joe’s, and during his time at Celtic Manor, he headed up the National Fitting Centres for both Titleist and Taylormade. He’s excited to bring his knowledge of hardware to Golf Monthly in the form of equipment reviews and buying advice.

Joe lives in North Devon and still plays sporadically on the PGA West region circuit. His best round in recent years came earlier in 2023 where he managed a 9 under par 63 at Trevose GC in a Devon & Cornwall PGA Tournament.

Joe's current What's In The Bag?

Driver: Switch between TaylorMade Qi35 and Callaway Elyte TD - both with Fujikura Ventus Black 6-X

Fairway wood 1: TaylorMade BRNR Copper Mini Driver - Fujikura Ventus Black 7-X

Fairway wood 2: Callaway Apex UW 17˚- Fujikura Ventus Black 9-X

Irons: TaylorMade P7CB 3-PW with Dynamic Gold Tour Issue X100 shafts

Wedges: Callaway Opus 50, 54, and 60 degrees - Project X LS 6.0 shafts

Putter: LAB Golf Oz.1 (zero shaft lean)

Ball: TaylorMade 2024 TP5x

Grips: Golf Pride Tour Velvet 60R

Bag: Vessel Player IV Pro DXR Stand

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.