When To Upgrade Your Irons

There's more to consider than just price when pondering when to upgrade your irons. Neil Tappin and Joel Tadman explain more in this video and piece...

When To Upgrade Your Irons
(Image credit: Golf Monthly)

When To Upgrade Your Irons

Your iron set is one of biggest purchases you’ll make as a golfer, so it’s worth spending time researching things properly and choosing the right moment to invest in an upgrade. Price is obviously a primary factor, but whether you’re looking to progress on to the best golf irons on the market or are looking more at the best budget irons, there are several other things to take into consideration.

WATCH: When To Upgrade Your Irons

Is your handicap coming down or going up?

Is your game improving or perhaps slipping the other way for whatever reason? Try to make an honest appraisal of where you feel your iron play is, because it can impact on both the timing of when to invest and what type of iron to look at. For example if you are going down then a mid-handicap iron (opens in new tab) could be on the cards, whereas if you are going up, one of the best game improvement models (opens in new tab) might be best.

Handicap coming down

Why do you think your handicap is coming down? If it’s down to improved ball-striking you might want to consider how best to keep that improvement going. It may be that an iron that helps you achieve consistency of strike is now perhaps less important than something that gives you a more consistent ball flight. Perhaps it could be time to move from more of a game improvement design to one of the best compact shallow cavity models to help you sustain your progress. Going even further down, you might eventually decide to put a set of blades (opens in new tab) in the bag as well for workability and feel.

srixon zx irons at address

(Image credit: Golf Monthly)

Handicap going up

Whether down to the passing years or perhaps a break from the game, your current irons may be geared towards feel and workability when what you actually now require is a little more strike assistance. If you’re not striking it out of the middle consistently, an iron that’s more stable and forgiving on off-centre hits (opens in new tab), or a bit more confidence-inspiring to look down on, could be the answer – more of a game improvement model.

But whichever way your handicap is going, don’t just assume that your iron play is the underlying reason. Try and keep some stats or records to shed some light on where your weaknesses lie as it’s only worth upgrading your irons if you can see scope for potential gains.

Feel and sound

These are important but not always easy to quantify. Feel and sound are perhaps where irons have improved the most in recent years.

Game improvement and mid-handicap irons in particular sound and feel much better than they did five to ten years ago, especially on off-centre hits. You’ll get better feel more often now even when you’re not finding the middle. The new breed of hollow-headed irons, geared up for more distance, also now sound much better – much less tinny and clicky than in the past.

Swing changes

Many golfers have lessons to improve, but as your technique changes, it can be that your current irons no longer suit your new swing and may be holding you back. For example, if your current irons have a fair amount of offset to help counter a fade or slice and you’ve now ironed that shape out, that offset will now be causing pulls or hooks.

shafts

Being aware of shaft flex is an important part of this discussion

(Image credit: Golf Monthly )

Think about shaft flex too. If you’re improving and generating more swing speed, it may be that a stiffer flex is required. Conversely, if your swing is slowing down with age, it may be that the stiff shafts you’ve played all your life are no longer suitable and are now actually holding you back.

Distance

Accuracy may be more important than distance with irons (opens in new tab), but that hasn’t stopped manufacturers making big strides on the distance front. If you’ve been losing distance, upgrading to a modern set of irons might help you recoup some of that. It’s no secret that iron lofts have got stronger, with today’s 7-iron perhaps boasting the 5-iron loft of yesteryear.

But even though spin will be lower too, we’ve found that ball flight has remained pretty similar – so it’s still easy to get that stronger 7-iron up in the air, with descent angles remaining similarly steep for equal stopping power.

A couple of things to beware of, though – the number on the bottom of club means less than in past. We’ve seen 7-iron lofts from 26˚ up to 34˚, which can make a significant difference from set to set. And finding more distance with your irons may create gapping issues at both ends of the bag, so an iron upgrade may also mean having to tweak or refine your hybrid and wood line-up or your wedges to prevent big gaps emerging.

Looks

This is a personal thing - it’s all about confidence over the ball. If you’re not comfortable with what you’re looking down on, that can lead to poor swings. One big improvement of late has been in the looks of game improvement irons – they’re a little bit more compact and sleek-looking, which some mid- to high-handicappers may prefer.

Other golfers prefer a chunkier look over the ball, and many brands have also introduced quite large-headed irons – some even more hybrid-style throughout the set. These can be more forgiving and easier to launch. Only you can decide what you like to look down on – for example, how thick a topline, how much offset?

taylormade p-series irons

(Image credit: Golf Monthly)

In some irons you can even see the back of the cavity at address, which some golfers may like and others may not. If you’re not keen, always check out the long irons in particular where this will be most obvious.

So, when to upgrade your irons? We’re not going to say every five years, seven years or whatever, although the faces and grooves will deteriorate over time, especially if you play a lot of golf. It’s less about time, and much more about what’s going on in your golf game and which way it’s heading.

For more iron buying advice, check out our guides on the best irons for seniors (opens in new tab), or best irons for beginners (opens in new tab)

Neil Tappin
Digital Editor

In his current role, Neil is responsible for testing drivers and golf balls. Having been a part of the Golf Monthly team for over 15 years and playing off a handicap of 3, he has the experience to compare performance between models, brands and generations. For 2022 he thinks the main trend in drivers is: "In a word, consistency. Whilst all the brands are talking about ball speed (and the new drivers are certainly long), my biggest finding has been how much more consistent the ball flights are. Mishits don't seem to be causing the same level of drop-off or increase in the spin numbers. This means that more shots seem to be flying the way you want them to!" As far as golf balls are concerned the biggest development is in the, "three piece, non-Tour, urethane-covered section. For regular golfers, these models offer superb performance at both ends of the bag without denting your wallet quite as much as the premium Tour-played options."


Originally working with the best coaches in the UK to produce instruction content, he is now the brand's Digital Editor and covers everything from Tour player interviews to gear reviews. In his time at Golf Monthly, he has covered equipment launches that date back well over a decade. He clearly remembers the launch of the Callaway and Nike square drivers as well as the white TaylorMade driver families, such as the RocketBallz! If you take a look at the Golf Monthly YouTube channel, you'll see his equipment videos dating back over a decade! He has also conducted 'What's In The Bag' interviews with many of the game's best players like Rory McIlroy, Dustin Johnson and Jon Rahm. Over the years, Neil has tested a vast array of products in each category and at drastically different price-points. 

Neil is currently playing: Driver: TaylorMade Stealth Plus Fairway Wood: Titleist TSR2 Hybrid: Titleist TS3 Irons (4-9): Mizuno JPX 919 Forged Wedges: Titleist Vokey SM7 46˚, 50˚, 54˚, 60˚ Putter: Odyssey Triple Track Ten Ball: Titleist Pro V1X

With contributions from