Brian Harman Should Be Revered Not Jeered For Tiger-Like Open Clinic

The American faced a few boos at Royal Liverpool – but his performance at The Open deserved better

Brian Harman Wins The 151st Open Championship
Brian Harman poses with the Claret Jug after his masterclass at Hoylake
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Number 151 is in the books. Brian Harman is your ‘Champion Golfer of the Year’. It’s probably fair to say that he’s not the winner that everyone wanted, certainly not for the majority of those who were actually on the ground at Hoylake demanding to be entertained. How dare this relatively unknown American bore the pants off us with his near-faultless golf. The audacity.

When Harman arrived on the first tee on Sunday with a five-shot lead, he was met with a smattering of boos from the galleries. It was the frosty reception, he said, that made him determined to complete the job. “If they wanted me to not play well they should have been really nice to me,” he said in his press conference afterwards. In other words, ‘Have some of that!’

Playing ‘boring’ albeit excellent golf, as some have called it, is not something the likes of Harman, a mere two-time PGA Tour winner, is allowed to do. Only a few players in the history of the game have ever had this privilege, Tiger Woods being the best example. Had it been he who had plotted his way around Hoylake with such devastating success, and in such rancid conditions, we'd have all approved.

The problem for Harman – or rather it could have been – was that there were so many tantalising storylines bubbling away ahead of him: Rahm and Hovland hunting the hunter (he likes using a bow and arrow in case you didn't know); hometown hero and Royal Liverpool member, Matthew Jordan, being cheered on almost deliriously by the locals; Alex Fitzpatrick outshining his more famous elder brother, Matthew, in his first ever Major; Southport-born Tommy Fleetwood desperately trying to win a dream Open in front of his adoring fans; and, of course, Rory McIlroy equally desperate to win that elusive fifth Major.

Harman was never go to be a hugely popular winner, not in these parts at least. The boos were almost predictable. Thankfully, come the time Harman made his way up the 18th, there was only generous applause – the type The Open is renowned for – for the man who was by far and away the best player of the week. The jeers, no doubt fuelled by one or two pints of Singha, were drowned out.

Ian Poulter, who didn’t qualify for this year’s Open, offered the American some kind words on Twitter: “For all those that gave him sh*t from the stands and waggle meters on TV and anyone else undermining his performance,” he said. “You should be ashamed. He outplayed the very best. Now respect him for that. Waggle away Brian.”

Well said. Still, it seems likely that the 151st Open Championship won’t go down as a thriller – and that’s Harman’s fault. When he left the door slightly ajar, he quickly slammed it shut. When he dropped a shot, he rebounded with a great putt. And when the fans heckled him, his resolve only strengthened.

Perhaps what he should have done was offer the chasing pack a bit more hope. Maybe, had he made a horlicks of the 17th, or pulled a couple out of bounds on 18, we’d have had ourselves that thriller. He could have beaten Rahm and McIlroy in a playoff – and we’d all have gone home far happier having witnessed something special.

The fact is, we did – it was just that no one else could keep up to make for a more interesting finish. As someone also remarked: “At the sharp end there was an absence of drama. That shouldn’t stop us admiring and praising Brian though. Superb effort.”

Michael Weston
Contributing editor

Michael has been with Golf Monthly since 2008. As a multimedia journalist, he has also worked for The Football Association, where he created content to support the men's European Championships, The FA Cup, London 2012, and FA Women's Super League. As content editor at Foremost Golf, Michael worked closely with golf's biggest equipment manufacturers, and has developed an in-depth knowledge of this side of the industry. He's now a regular contributor, covering instruction, equipment and feature content. Michael has interviewed many of the game's biggest stars, including six world number ones, and has attended and reported on many Major Championships and Ryder Cups. He's a member of Formby Golf Club.