The Biggest Equipment-Changing Disasters In Professional Golf
Often a gear change works wonders, but sometimes switching equipment doesn't go to plan at all


The two best golfers of all time barely ever changed their equipment. Tiger Woods had the same specs for all those years when he was at the peak of his powers and his bag set-up was rarely disturbed.
Jack Nicklaus, meanwhile, played with the same 3-wood for 37 years. His MacGregor 693 was in the bag for all 18 of his Major victories. What’s equally remarkable is that between 1958 and 1995 he only had it regripped once.
Other players like to tinker and change equipment on a regular basis, especially those who aren’t locked into commercial deals.
Although there are plenty of examples out there of players making successful equipment changes - one of the most remarkable being John Daly putting a Wilson Invex driver in the bag just a few days before winning The Open in 1995 - there have also been a few high-profile disasters.
Justin Rose, Honma
Justin Rose signed a deal with Honma in 2019
This was a strange one. Justin Rose was the reigning FedEx Cup champion when he decided to part company with TaylorMade back in 2019 and sign a multi-year deal with Japanese manufacturer Honma.
Although he won the Farmers Insurance Open in just his second week using Honma clubs and got to World No.1, it wasn’t that long before cracks started to appear and Rose began to miss a few cuts.
The Englishman dropped to No.14, and when he turned up at the Arnold Palmer Invitational in the March of 2020 without a single Honma club in his bag, it was clear that he wasn't happy with his equipment.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
Two months later, Honma and Rose announced in a joint statement that they had mutually agreed to part ways.
Fortunately for Rose, this equipment change didn’t totally derail his career. As we saw at this year’s Masters, all appears well again.
Bubba Watson, Volvik
Bubba Watson shows off his pink Volvik golf ball
It might have seemed like a bit of a surprise when Bubba Watson switched to using a bright-colored Volvik golf ball at the start of 2017, but this was a move that very much suited his brand.
The two-time Masters champion is well known for his crazy shot-shaping abilities, but clearly the ball did not suit his ball flight characteristics.
"My contract is done with Volvik. I do not have a ball deal as we sit here today," Watson told reporters at the Shriners Hospitals for Children Open in November.
"So I can play with whatever ball I want to. My deal was up, and so I'm ball-free."
Watson returned to using a Titleist Pro V1x. What a balls-up.
Phil Mickelson, Callaway
Phil Mickelson tees off with a new driver during Friday's fourballs at the 2004 Ryder Cup
What? How could Phil Mickelson’s switch from Titleist to Callaway ever be called a disaster? Well, let us explain.
Mickelson put Callaway clubs in the bag just a week before the 2004 Ryder Cup, which left a lot of people scratching their heads. The timing didn’t seem right.
When the American lost both of his matches on the opening day playing alongside Tiger Woods, it did not look like a wise decision.
After leaving his teammate in a few awkward spots with some wayward driving, ‘Lefty’ took a fair bit of flak.
Woods wasn’t impressed and nor was the US captain, Hal Sutton, who didn’t send Mickelson out on Saturday morning.
"Phil created a lot of drama that week, if we remember, because he switched his clubs and his ball prior to that week," Sutton told GolfChannel.com.
"It was very self-serving for him to do that prior to the Ryder Cup in 2004. So, if he needs me to shoulder the blame for his poor play, I can do that."
Anyway, let’s not reopen old wounds. In terms of the long term, Mickelson enjoyed a pretty healthy (and wealthy) 20-year relationship with Callaway.
Bryson DeChambeau, Krank Golf
Bryson DeChambeau's switch to a new driver head at the US Open almost proved a costly mistake
Only Bryson DeChambeau would change his driver head 20 minutes before teeing off in the final round of a US Open.
Yes, this maverick golfer went on to win his second US Open, but Sunday at Pinehurst could so nearly have turned into a disaster.
Due to the great speed that he generates, DeChambeau believes it’s not long before the face of his driver can start to flatten, slow and deform.
He has become known as ‘The Scientist’, so who are we to say there’s no truth in this? Even so, changing heads just before he went out with a three-shot lead in a Major Championship seemed a bit bonkers.
In the final round, he hit just five of 13 fairways, and he needed his short game to get him out of trouble, plus a little help from Rory McIlroy.
Anyway, here’s what he had to say after his round.
“I probably shouldn’t have changed the heads. I was trying to get a fresh head in there. It had a good curvature on the face, but it was a little bit lower loft.
“For whatever reason, those lower lofted heads have been missing right. Consequently, I missed it right all day.
“A bit frustrating, but the face that I was using for the past three days was just starting to get flat. It was a nine-and-a-half-inch curvature. I won’t go over that.
“Essentially the face was starting to get a little flat. I wanted to get a fresh head in.”

Michael has been with Golf Monthly since 2008. A multimedia journalist, he has also worked for The Football Association, where he created content to support the England football team, The FA Cup, London 2012, and FA Women's Super League. As content editor at Foremost Golf, Michael worked closely with golf's biggest equipment manufacturers and has developed an in-depth knowledge of this side of the industry. He's a regular contributor, covering instruction, equipment, travel and feature content. Michael has interviewed many of the game's biggest stars, including seven World No.1s, and has attended and reported on numerous Major Championships and Ryder Cups around the world. He's a member of Formby Golf Club in Merseyside, UK.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
-
The Unusual Gear In The Bags Of The World’s Best Golfers... Including An LET Star Who Carries Two Putters And A PGA Tour Winner With Two 8-Irons
It's not all brand new and conventional when it comes to the bags of elite professional golfers, with one still using a 3-wood that's more than 10 years old...
-
My Unpopular Golf Opinion: Gimmes Should Be Banned In Professional And Elite Amateur Match Play
Joe Ferguson has had enough of an age-old tradition in the game - gimmes.
-
How To Build The Best Set Of Clubs For Your Handicap
Joel Tadman takes a look at the data from Shot Scope to find out which clubs different abilities of golfer should consider adding to their bag to lower their scores
-
What Are The Rarest Second Hand Golf Clubs?
We speak to Europe’s largest retailer of second hand golf clubs, and discover this marketplace can be a treasure trove for hidden gems
-
3 Reasons To Add A Mini Driver To Your Golf Bag
The mini-driver has been popping up in more and more bags on professional tours all around the world in recent months. Could you be missing out if you haven't tried one yet?
-
Building The Ultimate Callaway Golf Bag: Our Favourite Clubs From The Brand’s History
We select the best and most legendary gear that Callaway has ever produced, from driver right through to putter...
-
Do You Need Stronger-Lofted Irons? The Arguments For And Against
Are you looking for greater distance? We look at the pros and cons of playing irons with stronger lofts
-
What Is My Putter Worth?
Is now the time to part with your flatstick? You might be wondering how much it's worth, but there are many factors to consider that will affect its value...