Fergus Bisset thinks approaching the green with a full shot is always preferable to facing a tricky little pitch… Jeremy Ellwood doesn’t agree…

Why Leaving A Full Shot To The Green Will Save You Strokes

Hit a full shot

says Fergus Bisset

For those with the touch of Phil Mickelson, playing down close to a green where short game wizardry can come to the fore may well be a desirable option.

But for the 99% of golfers whose touch is more akin to Phil Mitchell’s, leaving a full wedge shot into a green is preferable.

There are few shots in golf that are more difficult to judge and execute than a half shot or pitch from relatively close range.

How much swing to take, how much power to take off, will it spin, will I catch it clean?

There’s so much that can go wrong and so little chance for amateur golfers to get it absolutely spot on.

The super-destructive duff or knife are all too possible, and they get into the head.

With a full shot from a favoured yardage, the equation is simple – make a good swing, hit it firmly and the result will be reasonable at worst and excellent at best.

A full shot with a wedge will stop quickly when fired into all but the firmest greens, allowing you to control the distance effectively.

If you know how far each of your scoring clubs goes with a full swing, and you know the exact yardage to the pin, you’ll have a clear game plan.

From shorter range, indecision will creep in. Whether to loft it and attempt to get it to stop quickly or to allow for more run – that indecision can lead to a lack of commitment, a deceleration and disaster.

In a pressure situation, what would you rather face – a full swing from 100 yards where you can give it a bit of welly, or a fiddly pitch from 40 yards that requires smooth finesse and a perfect contact? I know where I stand – full shot every time.

Why Leaving A Full Shot To The Green Will Save You Strokes

Play for the pitch

says Jeremy Ellwood

This debate really comes to the fore on short par 4s and certain par 5s where you face strategic choices.

Do you try to chase it down there as far as possible, leaving a mere flick or pitch in, or do you hold back or lay up to leave a fuller approach?

The sensible choice must be to maximise distance if relatively safe to do so for one simple reason – for most golfers, the shorter the shot, the closer to the flag they’re likely to hit it.

The full shot merchant will argue that longer approaches generate more spin and therefore greater control.

But at club level, we misjudge, mis-strike or misclub full shots far more often than the world’s best, and what control we do have will be of little benefit if we’re 15 yards long, short or wide.

Even the best iron player on the PGA Tour from 125 to 150 yards – not surprisingly Collin Morikawa in 2021 – averages 16ft 5ins from the pin.

The reality is that for club golfers, the fuller the swing, the more scope there is for something to go badly wrong.

The clubface doesn’t have to be involuntarily twisted many degrees open or closed for accuracy to drop off dramatically. The more compact the swing, as with a pitch, the less likelihood there is of the clubface getting so far out of sync.

And even if it does, a couple of degrees out from 50 yards will only equate to a relatively minor miss.

The moral of the tale therefore is: to increase the number of birdie chances you create, play to leave yourself as many pitch approaches as the course sensibly allows. Yes, it may sometimes backfire, but overall you will score better.