When the threat of HS2 – the proposed new high-speed railway between London and Birmingham initially, then on further north – first reared its ugly head at Whittington Heath Golf Club, I travelled up in 2011 to find out more from then captain, John Tipper…

Studying plans for the proposed HS2 line with 2011 captain, John Tipper

Five years ago…
When the Labour government announced in 2009 that it was examining the case for a new high-speed railway (HS2) from London to first the Midlands, then eventually on to Scotland, there were always going to be winners and losers along the proposed route. Until December 2009, Whittington Heath, a long-established star of Staffordshire golf, found itself somewhere between the two – unlikely to escape unscathed, but facing a seemingly manageable impact on its beautiful heathland course.

Whittington Heath’s beautiful heathland layout

Then on December 20, 2010 the coalition government delivered a festive downer that would have delighted Scrooge himself – where the original route had clipped the edges of the course, the revised route ploughed through the clubhouse, hurtled on down the 9th fairway, and exited by the 7th green, effectively cutting this Harry Colt classic in half – decades of history potentially wiped out for a mere 20 seconds of travel time.

2011 captain, John Tipper, points out where HS2 will cut through

As Tipper, the man with the dubious honour of the 2011 captaincy, quipped before our more serious conversation, “They saw me coming, didn’t they! We knew it was scheduled to come through and we knew it would clip the corner off the course, but we didn’t have a problem with that because we own more land, which isn’t currently part of the course. It would have affected the 15th hole, and probably the 16th tee, and we thought with a bit of redesign we could shore things up without any major problems.”

That all changed when the revised route burst straight through the clubhouse doors. While it may be sad that a building that has also served as a racecourse grandstand and soldiers’ home looks set to end up as railway rubble, Tipper’s focus really lay outside. “What’s upsetting is that it’s a very old, long-established club, which a lot of people are very…” “…emotionally attached to?” I interjected when he struggled for the right words. “Yes,” he nodded.

The golf course lies just beyond the bus

“But not only that – there are a lot of people who very much applaud the club for what it is, the quality of the course and so on. It’s not the clubhouse we’re most concerned about,” he continued, waving his arms in the direction of the course. “That’s our prize asset; that’s what people appreciate.”

Autumn 2016…
Thankfully, on September 20 this year, Whittington Heath was able to announce a resolution satisfactory to all parties with the approval of plans to preserve the future of its 130 year-old club and course following extensive consultation over the last five years with HS2 – a consultation believed to be the first of its kind relating to the HS2 project.

HS2 is currently slated to cut through eight acres of the course resulting in the loss of five holes, the historic clubhouse and the greenkeeper’s compound. The Government has now agreed to pay for major redevelopment on adjoining land that will pave the way to a replacement clubhouse, five new holes, a practice range, a reworking of five existing holes and a new car park. Highly regarded course architect, Jonathan Gaunt, is the man enlisted with creating the new holes and effecting the other changes to the golf course.

An artist’s impression of the proposed new clubhouse area and some of the new holes

The work affecting Whittington Heath will be carried out as part of HS2 phase one. Club captain Pete Espin commented following the announcement: “After consultation with members about the course of action we should take, we made a conscious decision to work with HS2 and preserve 130 years of golf and a much longer history for the overall site. We could simply have accepted the HS2 route as a signal for the course’s closure but we’ve worked closely with them and we’re delighted with the outcome under the circumstances.”

A HS2 spokesperson said: “We are delighted that the members of Whittington Heath Golf Club have been able to secure new land that will enable its long golfing traditions to continue into the future.”

So all’s well that ends well. Of course, no golf club would really want a major railway line cutting through its tranquil pride and joy, but this has been all about finding the best possible solution for all parties given that the proposed route for the line had edged towards immovable status.

It is good news indeed that the club’s future has been secured and that all seem happy with the outcome, notwithstanding the considerable disruption that all the work will bring over the coming years.