The Putting Myth That's Harming Your One-Putt Potential

Putting expert James Jankowski explains why golfers fall foul of a common misconception regarding how the putter moves and shares what you should do instead

James Jankowski showing a common putting myth about how the putter is believed to move in the stroke, showing the angle of the face from a horizontal plane, with an inset of James hitting a putt
James Jankowski busts a common myth about how the putter moves (and it could save you strokes on the green)
(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Some people believe that playing with a low number on your golf ball brings luck or if you tap the inside of the cup with the ball after a good putt that run will continue - but let's face it... these are nonsensical myths.

Those particular examples are fairly harmless, but one particular putting myth is actually costing you shots on the green - and that can't continue if you want to improve!

Putting is an often neglected art in the amateur game, which is a travesty when you consider that tools like our ultimate putting improvement guide can help you shoot lower scores and cut your handicap by shaving shots off the card on the green.

James Jankowksi, a putting expert who has helped over 3000 golfers to sharpen up on the greens, believes that a common misconception around how the putter moves is the cause of great pain for amateur golfers.

Below, James busts the myth and shares his expert advice on how you can putt better for the remainder of the season...

The Putting Myth That's Harming Your One-Putt Potential

First, you need to understand how the putter moves.

At address, the shaft sits on an inclined plane, so the putter swings naturally on an arc, and the face gradually opens during the backstroke.

A common mistake is trying to keep the face square to the target, or simply not allowing it to open enough.

James Jankowski demonstrating the position of the putter when viewing on a horizontal plane

If you lowered the putter back down to ground level here, the face would be pointing left, leading to a pulled putt

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Relative to the putter's natural arc, this means the face is now effectively shut.

Viewing it on a horizontal plane shows that it really is actually shut, indicating the amount of rotation, and therefore timing, needed to return it to square.

If you don't, you will pull the putt. If you do, you've introduced a timing element that can just as easily lead to you pushing it.

James Jankowksi demonstrating the opposite effect, where the face is now open and leading to a pushed putt

Overcompensating can equally lead to a pushed putt

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Pulled putts often stem from having to create speed too near impact. A good stroke relies on timing.

If the backstroke is too slow and short, you have to accelerate late into the ball.

GLF331.shortgame.dsc03829_1

Too short a backstroke, as here, means accelerating into the ball to create speed, which will lead to timing issues at impact

(Image credit: Unknown)

The later you create speed, the harder it is to time the stroke.

Some golfers tilt (push) or rotate (pull) excessively at impact; others stall the handle and flip the putter head (pull) or drive the handle (push).

James Jankowski past impact with the putter

When you have to create speed this way, your timing suffers

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Many golfers are told to hit up on the ball to create topspin but that's not why we want a slight upward angle of attack.

At address, the ball's equator sits around 6-8mm above the putter's sweet spot, so a slight upward strike simply helps return the centre of the face to the equator.

It's a strike function, not a topspin function.

James Jankowski demonstrating the natural shoulder tilt when using the conventional grip

The shoulder tilt in a conventional putting grip helps to promote an upward strike

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

With a conventional putting grip, a small amount of shoulder tilt at address naturally encourages an upward strike.

Those who consciously try to create topspin often manipulate the putter, introducing another timing element.

Get it right and you'll get away with it; get it wrong and the face or path won't return consistently, leading to pushes and pulls.

James Jankowski
Top 50 Coach

Location: Old Fold Manor 


James has been coaching golf for 10 years and specialising in putting for more than six. In the past three years James has worked with more than 3000 golfers, including more than 200 professionals. If he was to single out a success it would be seeing Jamie Rutherford win the EuroPro Tour order of merit this year after working together for the past three years. His philosophy is simple – 'We do whatever it takes to make each individual better on the greens.’ 


A typical lesson:

It almost doesn’t exist, due to each session being catered to the individual. However, the general structure of a new client may be similar. I would start with an analysis of their current putting game. This would involve using video analysis, Capto and Quintic data, hitting putts from varying distances and break directions, asking appropriate questions the whole time. My goal in the opening 15-20 minutes of a session, is to understand the areas within which the client can find the biggest and fastest gains. I’m not just looking at their technique, I’m looking at their process and routines, asking them about their approach, and more. 


Analysis of performance:

Keeping putting stats is extremely important to be able to notice tendencies and trends. My favourite stats app being Spider Putt. This allows me to notice these trends for specific putts, by both distance and slope amount. I have also composed a document of performance games for students to do during sessions or in their own time. This allows for in depth assessment over time in specific areas. 


Most common problem: 

Probably speed control. This usually starts with a lack of understanding of what they should be trying to achieve. More often than not, if they can fully understand what their goal is with acceleration in the stroke, they have a far greater chance of achieving it. I also have a bunch of great drills to help them improve their technique and enhance their skills. 


With contributions from

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.