This Common Short Putting Misconception Is Holding You Back (Here’s How To Hole More)

Missing a short putt is hugely frustrating, but the reality is you could be the victim of a common misconception... which our expert is ready to dispel!

James Jankowski hitting a short putt on the green with the ball travelling towards the hole, with another image of the ball dropping into the hole
Holing more short putts is a realistic ambition for all golfers... but beware of this common misconception
(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Missing a short putt on the golf course is one of the most infuriating experiences for any player - regardless of ability or experience within the game.

There are plenty of great tips and drills on how to hole out more often from short range in our ultimate putting improvement guide, or our tailored high-handicapper's putting manual, but many amateurs don't realise they are stifling their potential due to a common misconception.

According to putting expert James Jankowksi, who has helped more than 3000 golfers to improve on the greens, the idea that you should never aim outside the hole for a short putt is misleading.

Below, James explains why and shares his top tips to help you hole more short putts on the course...

This Common Short Putting Misconception Is Holding You Back

Before we start, let's look at the latest Shot Scope data to see what sort of success rate you should be looking for from 0-3ft.

Benchmarking yourself against the average amateur in your handicap index bracket is a great exercise to help you understand your starting point, which you can then build on with James' expert tips below.

Short Putt Success Rate (0-3ft)

Percentage of putts holed from 0-3ft by amateur golfers in different handicap index brackets

% Putts Made (0-3ft)

0-handicap
98
5-handicap
96
10-handicap
96
15-handicap
93
20-handicap
90
25-handicap
88
0255075100
% Putts Made (0-3ft) Data
ProductValue
0-handicap98
5-handicap96
10-handicap96
15-handicap93
20-handicap90
25-handicap88

Common Misconception (Short Putts)

Many amateurs try to take the break out of short putts. Sometimes this can be effective but it often leads to under-reading and lip-outs.

There's a common idea that you should never aim outside the hole on short putts. That's misleading as short putts still break.

James Jankowski hitting a short putt and dispelling a common misconception that you shouldn't aim outside the hole for short length putts

Think about your entry point even on short putts that break

(Image credit: Photography: Howard Boylan)

This also introduces the idea of an effective centre or entry point. For example, on a left-to-right putt as here, the effective centre of the cup shifts slightly to the left of the physical centre.

Visualising where the ball is most likely to enter helps clarify the intended start line and improves spatial awareness relative to that entry point. Start picturing and feeling that entry point.

The Role Of The Hands

Short putts are a different motor task to longer putts. A 3-footer is not a scaled-down 40-footer – it is a fine motor movement.

Longer putts rely on a larger, more rhythmic motion from the shoulders and torso to generate energy, but intricate movements are typically felt through the hands, even though the stroke is coordinated through the whole body.

A close up of James Jankowski gripping his putter

Intricate movements, like those needed to hole short putts, are felt through the hands

(Image credit: Unknown)

On short putts, the hands provide the sensory ‘read' for the movement, helping to organise timing and face control without excessive motion. Feel the smooth motion in the hands and putter, and the rest will often follow.

James Jankowski with a very light, thumbs off grip on his putter

The hands provide the sensory read for movement with short putts

(Image credit: Unknown)

Entry Speed

Even on short putts, entry speed matters. The ball needs enough momentum to hold a true roll but not so much that the hole effectively shrinks.

‘Capture size' is the effective opening of the hole at different speeds.

A golf ball falling into the hole after a short putt

The size of the hole effectively varies according to pace

(Image credit: Unknown)

The more speed, the smaller the hole effectively becomes and the less ability to drop the ball has. But at around 0.95mph or below, the ball's roll loses stability, with more chance of it wobbling or drifting offline late on.

Aim for it to enter the hole with some momentum, not dribbling in the front or ramming into the back.

Mark Townsend
Contributing editor

Mark has worked in golf for over 20 years having started off his journalistic life at the Press Association and BBC Sport before moving to Sky Sports where he became their golf editor on skysports.com. He then worked at National Club Golfer and Lady Golfer where he was the deputy editor and he has interviewed many of the leading names in the game, both male and female, ghosted columns for the likes of Robert Rock, Charley Hull and Dame Laura Davies, as well as playing the vast majority of our Top 100 GB&I courses. He loves links golf with a particular love of Royal Dornoch and Kingsbarns. He is now a freelance, also working for the PGA and Robert Rock. Loves tour golf, both men and women and he remains the long-standing owner of an horrific short game. He plays at Moortown with a handicap of 6.


With contributions from

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.