'Play It As It Lies, Suck It Up And Show Us What You Are Made Of' – What's Your Opinion On The Mud Ball Debate At The PGA Championship?
Mud balls are the talk of the PGA Championship, with some of the world's best players venting their frustration... but what do you think? Have your say...


Day one at the PGA Championship produced some interesting storylines, perhaps the biggest of which relates to the prevalence of mud balls at a rain beaten Quail Hollow.
Xander Schauffele and Scottie Scheffler weighed in on the mud ball controversy following their opening rounds at the second Major of the season, but do you agree with them?
Do you sympathise when you listen to elite level tour players complain about unfortunate breaks on the golf course, or is your stance very much play it as it lies and get one with it?
Either way, we'd love to hear your thoughts on the matter... comment in the box at the bottom of this article and we will share some of the best responses in a new article over the weekend.
My Opinion: Jeopardy Is Good For The Game Of Golf
I can sympathise with any elite athlete who spends their life preparing for their specialist sport only to be hampered by an ill-timed twist of fate - but that's also part of the reason we love to watch competitive sport.
The twists and turns, the jeopardy in the closing stages, it's all crucial to creating a spectacle - one that truly befits a Major Championship in my opinion.
I'm not saying that mud balls are a good thing for Major Championship golf, but I do believe that watching the same incredibly talented players rip up golf courses and post ludicrously low scores is an absolute snore-fest.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
When you see the entire field negotiating a new challenge, like the one they are facing at Quail Hollow this week, it peaks the interest of the average golfer who wants to see how the world's best cope with the challenges that the everyday golfer struggles with.
Scottie Scheffler was openly frustrated with the mud ball situation at the PGA Championship
If that means Scheffler and Schauffele hit one in the water and make a big score, so be it. The whole thing will even itself out over the course of the week, like it always does, and ultimately the one who copes best will emerge victorious.
Whether players find a divot, mud balls or bad bounces, the most resilient will battle back and surge up the PGA Championship leaderboard.
Coming down the stretch on Sunday, I'd love to see a few twists and turns, a battle against adversity and an exciting finish that could go one way or another until the final player finds the solace of the putting surface on 18.
My overarching sentiment - play it as it lies, suck it up and show us what your made of!
Even after hitting the ball into the middle of the fairway, players were not immune from the odd mud ball at Quail Hollow during the first round of the PGA Championship
What Have The Golf Monthly Readers Said So Far?
As you might expect with a divisive issue such as this, there have been mixed responses, and after posting Scheffler's comments to our Instagram page yesterday, we received some interesting comments.
A post shared by Golf Monthly (@golfmonthly)
A photo posted by on
One said "Wake up and think of us club golfers playing every Sunday. We have mud on our balls. We have no sun like you do. We have no relief like you do. Get on and play the game".
Taking a similar stance, another wrote "Whining rarely comes off well when everyone is playing the same conditions and not complaining".
Interestingly, however, others had more sympathy for the players competing at the PGA Championship.
One said "Lift and clean should be standard...if in the fairway", while another added "I tend to agree, but now is not the time to be complaining".
Ultimately, the powers that be at the PGA Championship made the decision to play the ball as it lies, meaning you will naturally get some good and bad breaks. The question is, do you agree with that decision?

Barry joined Golf Monthly in January 2024, and now leads the instruction section across all platforms including print and digital. Working closely with Golf Monthly's Top 50 Coaches, he aims to curate and share useful tips on every aspect of the game - helping amateurs of all abilities to play better golf. A member at Sand Moor Golf Club in Leeds, he looks forward to getting out on the course at least once a week in the pursuit of a respectable handicap.
Barry is currently playing:
Driver: Benross Delta XT Driver
Hybrid: TaylorMade Stealth 4 Hybrid
Irons: Benross Delta XT 5-PW
Wedges: TaylorMade RAC 60, Callaway Jaws MD5 54
Putter: TaylorMade Spider Tour
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
-
Should Regular Golfers Use Long Irons Or Hybrids? The Answer Is More Complicated That You Might Think... Here Are The Arguments For Both Sides
We asked two golfers with different views and over 60 years combined experience for their thoughts
-
Eyeline Golf Speed Trap 2.0 Training Aid Review
Can the Eyeline Golf Speed Trap 2.0 lead to more consistent ball striking? Gear equipment expert Sam De’Ath finds out