Billy Horschel Eagles Second Playoff Hole To Win BMW PGA Championship From Rory McIlroy

The trio of Rory McIlroy, Thriston Lawrence and Billy Horschel all finished at 20-under-par and, at the second playoff hole, Horschel eagled to win the event for a second time

Billy Horschel holds the BMW PGA Championship trophy

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Heading into the final round of the DP World Tour's flagship event, it was Matteo Manassero who led by three strokes following a 54-hole tournament record of 18-under-par.

With nine holes remaining, it was Lawrence and Rai who led, with both men well under-par as they battled it out over the West Course. For Rai, though, he would rue a run of pars and a late bogey, as he finished in a share of fourth.

That meant it was Lawrence's to lose and, with a birdie at the 16th, he led by two strokes from McIlroy and Horschel. It was set up to be an epic and, after Lawrence parred in to set the target at 20-under, only the experienced duo could catch the South African.

Playing the 17th, McIlroy hit two stunning shots to find the green at the par 5 and, striking his putt from 45-feet, it never left the cup, with the eagle putting the four-time Major winner into a share of the lead. What's more, playing partner, Horschel, managed to birdie to get one back going down the 18th.

The drama wasn't done there, as Horschel very nearly holed his third from 90-yards for an eagle, whilst McIlroy nearly found the water with his second. The par for McIlroy and birdie for Horschel meant we headed to a three-way playoff, with all three finishing 20-under.

At the first, Lawrence found the water, whilst both Horschel and McIlroy birdied. Then, at the second playoff hole, the duo found the centre of the green, as both had makeable eagle opportunities.

Striking his putt first, McIlroy's attempt grazed the right edge, with his birdie leaving it up to Horschel to hole his putt for the win. Lining it up, the ball rolled end-over-end and never looked like missing and, as it got to the hole, it was Horschel's prize for a second time, with the 37-year-old becoming the first American to win at Wentworth twice. 

BMW PGA CHAMPIONSHIP LEADERBOARD

-20 Billy Horschel*

-20 Rory McIlroy, Thriston Lawrence

-17 Matteo Manassero, Aaron Rai, Matthew Baldwin

-16 Antoine Rozner, Ugo Coussaud, Niklas Norgaard

*Won with eagle at second playoff hole

Updates from...

Matt Cradock
Matt Cradock
Refresh

AARON RAI TAKES THE LEAD

SOLID APPROACH FROM MANASSERO

Manassero hasn't played well today but, with his second shot into the 11th, he is clearly thinking straight. Finding the fairway bunker, he sticks his wedge, from 140-yards, into the heart of the green. If he two putts, he will have the getable par 5 12th next.

In his group, Billy Horschel finds the right side of the green, whilst Rory McIlroy has just hit a monster drive of 335-yards! He's left with just 65-yards, but his approach goes slightly long and he will have a quick birdie putt coming back.

LAWRENCE JOINS THE LEADERS

Thriston Lawrence walks off the green in a white hoodie

(Image credit: Getty Images)

The South African birdies the par 5 12th and joins Rai at the top of the leaderboard. He is five-under for his round and now 18-under for his tournament.

RAI JUST MISSES BIRDIE AT 13

Another excellent approach from Rai leaves him a 10-foot putt for birdie which, just a few feet out, looks in. However, the putt dives at the end and just misses on the low side. It's a par for the Englishman, who looks in control of his game.

SUPERB FROM HORSCHEL

MONSTER FROM RORY

EAGLE FOR HORSCHEL, MANASSERO AND MCILROY BIRDIE

His approach deserved an eagle, and that's exactly what Horschel gets! It's the closet second shot we've seen at the 12th today, with his five-footer finding the centre of the cup. He is now 18-under and in a four-way tie for the lead.

EXCELLENT FROM HORSCHEL

Both Manassero and McIlroy miss the green at the par 4 13th and will have work to do to save their pars. It's a different story for Horschel, though, who puts another approach close, with his shot from 160-yards finishing 12-foot from the flag.

LAWRENCE LEADS

MISSED BIRDIE PUTT FOR RAI

Back on the 15th tee, Lawrence pulls his tee shot left but gets away with it, as the ball comes to the rest in the first cut. He'll have a line to the flag and a chance to find the green.

HORSCHEL SHARES THE LEAD

It's all action here at Wentworth! After a nice approach, Horschel rolls in the putt for a very handy eagle-birdie run on the 12th and 13th. He's timing this run nicely and, if he were to win, he would become the first American to claim victory at Wentworth twice.

HOW THINGS STAND...

MCILROY MAKES BIRDIE

Huge putt on the 14th from Rory. He hits a great approach on the par 3 and rolls in the putt to get the crowds making noise! He's birdied two of the last three holes and is now just one back of Lawrence and Horschel.

Speaking of Horschel, he misses his birdie attempt at the 14th, with a par keeping him 19-under. Up ahead, having got away with his tee shot on the 15th, Lawrence puts an iron from 200-yards into the heart of the green. He's faced with a mid-range putt which never looks in on impact. It's perfect weight, though, and he saves par on a potential banana skin hole.

RORY ON A CHARGE?

Rory McIlroy hits a driver off the tee

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Has Rory got the swagger back? After a birdie at the 14th he stripes his tee shot down the centre of the fairway at the tough 15th. The same can't be said for Horschel, who blocks his drive well right and, although he's missed the ditch, it will likely be a chip out. Last up is Manassero, who also blocks his drive right and, this time around, he isn't as lucky, with the ball finding the penalty area on the fly.

NORGAARD SHOOTS 64

SOLID APPROACH FROM MCILROY

HUGE FROM LAWRENCE

Is that the putt that puts his name on the trophy? There's still plenty of shots to be played, but Lawrence has just dealt a huge blow at the par 4 16th! Faced with 26-feet for birdie, the South African drains the putt and becomes the first player to move to 20-under.

MANASSERO FLAILING

Manassero's hopes of a victory seem to be coming to an end. Taking a drop, he's left with 240-yards, with his shot getting extremely lucky! It strikes a tree that stops it from going out of bounds. To be fair to the Italian, his fourth shot is very good and leaves him a good chance to save bogey.

THE WINNING PUTT?

LAWRENCE LEADS BY TWO

And, just like that, Lawrence's lead is two strokes! On the 15th, Horschel's par putt comes up just short and, after tapping-in, the American moves back to 18-under. In regards to McIlroy, he has an opportunity to get to 19-under, but his birdie attempt slides by the right side. 

LAWRENCE IN GOOD SHAPE

After a superb tee shot on the 17th, Lawrence fires a driving iron around 50-yards short of the green and will have another good look at making birdie. Elsewhere, on the green, Rai's charge has been halted, with five consecutive pars meaning he remains at 18-under. 

SOLID FROM RORY

At the 16th, McIlroy puts a wedge to around 15-feet and will have a good look at birdie. Like Manassero, you feel Horschel's momentum has dwindled as, from the same distance, his approach goes over the back of the green, with Manassero putting his shot on the short stuff, albeit far away.

MISTAKE FROM LAWRENCE

That pitch shot from the 27-year-old looked nervy... It looked a straight forward shot but, on impact, the ball doesn't bite and runs through the back. It seemed to be slightly thin and, on the fourth shot, Lawrence doesn't cover himself in glory, as a routine chip finishes four-feet from the flag.

RORY MISSES AT 16

It's a great chance for a birdie at the 16th, but McIlroy's attempt never looks like it's going in. Missing on the high side, he taps in for a par and remains two back of Lawrence, as does Horschel, who makes an up-and-down from the back of the green.

LAWRENCE TIDIES UP

FAIRWAY FINDERS

Teeing it up first, McIlroy finds the fairway on the right side of the 17th. He might be able to reach the green and, knowing Rory, he will likely go for it if he can. Horschel is up next and, although he lets go of his driver instantly, his tee shot finds the fairway, as does Manassero's, with all three on the short grass. 

RAI FINDS THE DRINK

Aaron Rai strikes an iron from the fairway

(Image credit: Getty Images)

It's a brave, brave shot from Rai at the 18th. Needing to eagle the last to share the lead with Lawrence, the Englishman goes at the flag but it doesn't fade. He finds the water and his hopes of a win have gone.

MCILROY FINDS THE GREEN AT 17

The four-time Major winner nails his fairway wood at the 17th and it's right down the line of the flag. Landing on the green, McIlroy is unlucky to not get an extra bounce nearer the hole, but it will be an eagle putt for the former BMW PGA Championship winner.

Up ahead, Lawrence hits a fairway for safety off the tee and, although he finds the short grass, he is well back of the green. Once again, he's left with the decision of whether to lay-up or go for it.

EAGLE FOR RORY

Wow! That is spectacular from McIlroy! What an eagle putt at the 71st hole from 45-feet to pull level alongside Lawrence at 20-under! 

LAWRENCE LAYS UP

Lawrence has opted to lay up from the fairway and leaves himself a wedge shot from around 120-yards. Back on the 17th, Horschel makes a birdie and moves to 19-under, just one back of Lawrence and McIlroy. He's still not out of it!

LAWRENCE HOLDS ON

It's a great angle in to the 18th flag for Lawrence, but his approach is very conservative and not close to the flag at all. He'll have around 30-feet for birdie and, with Rory safely in the fairway, you could argue that he now has the advantage, especially as Horschel has found the fairway bunker off the tee. 

JUST SHORT

Finally, a big shout out goes to Matthew Baldwin, who birdies the last to finish 17-under and in a share of fourth. That's an excellent result for the Englishman, who has likely secured his DP World Tour card for next season.

THAT'S VERY LUCKY

LUCKY BREAK

SO GOOD FROM BILLY

Rory's up next...

CHANCE FOR THE WIN

Not his best but, coming from the rough and with water short, you can't blame McIlroy for firing that pitch past the flag. He will have around 15-feet, downhill, for the victory.

SO GOOD FROM BILLY

WE HEAD TO A PLAYOFF

McIlroy's attempt isn't even close as he misses on the right side. That's a final round 67 for Rory, who produced a gutsy eagle at the 17th to force the initiative. 

It's not just McIlroy who will be in the playoff either! Horschel makes a clutch four down the 18th to join McIlroy and Lawrence in the playoff, which will be played down the par 5 18th.

WHO IS YOUR MONEY ON?

ADVANTAGE HORSCHEL AND McIlroy

Horschel steps up first and pounds his drive into position A1. He's right at the end of the fairway and has a clear line to the flag, some 210-yards from the green.

Up next is Lawrence, who carves his tee shot well right and won't be able to get to the green from there. A lay-up won't be easy either, with the South African needing to hit a big fade just to get it back in play.

Finally, it's the turn of McIlroy, who also smashes his 3-wood into a great position. Importantly, he will hit in to the green before Horschel, so could put some pressure on the American with a good shot.

LAWRENCE FINDS THE BUNKER

It's a tricky shot and, aiming at the hospitality tents, Lawrence tops his fairway wood off a bare lie. It finishes in the bunker and well back of the green. 

STILL ANYONE'S

It's Rory's turn to hit and, striking a long iron, it finishes over the green but on the correct side. He will have plenty of green to work with from the chip shot. 

Horschel steps up and pushes his approach right into the greenside bunker. Again, he'll have plenty of green to work with, but both are very difficult up-and-downs for birdie.

LAWRENCE FINDS THE WATER

It was a tough, tough shot, especially from that lie, but Lawrence finds the water. It's a great effort from the 27-year-old, who managed to pitch it on the green, however, the ball spins back into the ditch and his hopes of a title have gone.

SLIGHT COMMOTION

Lawrence takes a drop and sticks his wedge shot next to the flag. That'll be for a bogey, though. Up ahead on the green, Horschel is forced to wait for the South African to mark his ball, with Horschel getting slightly hot-under-the-collar as he was about to hit from the sand.

NOT BAD FROM McIlroy

It's a tough shot for Rory and, although he gets a bad bounce, his chip finishes pin high. It'll be down to the putting and, putting first, you could say it's advantage Rory...

MCILROY AND HORSCHEL MAKE BIRDIE

PERFECT FROM BOTH

Heading back up the 18th, it's a carbon copy of their tee shots from 20 minutes ago. Horschel strikes his driver perfectly, leaving around 200-yards in, whilst Rory pummels a 3-wood that finishes behind his opponent. He is slightly further back than last time, though, so could be in between clubs for his approach...

OUTSTANDING FROM BOTH

He's 235-yards back, but Rory strikes a classy long iron to the centre of the green and leaves himself an eagle putt of about 30-odd feet. The pressure is on Horschel, but he steps up and replicates his opponent's shot, with the 37-year-old leaving himself slightly longer than McIlroy on a similar line.

THE MEASURING STICK IS OUT

I said that Horschel would be first, but the angle doesn't do it justice and it will actually be McIlroy to go first.

GREAT EFFORT FROM RORY

HORSCHEL WINS

What a putt from Billy Horschel! His eagle attempt never looks anywhere else as it rolls into the cup for the win. It's his second victory at Wentworth, with Horschel becoming the first American to win this tournament twice. What an epic final day!

WHAT A WAY TO WIN

HISTORY MAKER

Billy Horschel holds the BMW PGA Championship trophy

(Image credit: Getty Images)

What an afternoon at Wentworth... Congratulations to Billy Horschel, a two-time winner of the BMW PGA Championship!