9 Hole Match: Can Newer Golf Clubs Close The Ability Gap?

We gave golfers of different handicaps a staggered budget to buy a set of clubs to see if the amount you pay can even up the scoring over nine holes

9 hole match gol
(Image credit: Future)

Golf equipment marketing constantly promises lower scores, longer drives and ultimate forgiveness. But can dropping serious cash on the latest technology actually compensate for a lower skill level?

To settle the debate, three of the Golf Monthly team headed to the stunning Berkhamsted Golf Club to put this theory to the test. Three golfers of different skill levels - a +4 handicap, a 3-handicap and an 8-handicap - played a 9-hole match. Each player was given free rein to build a bag from the golfclubs4cash website, but the lower the handicap, they less they had to spend.

Can a high-end, modern setup help a mid-handicapper go toe-to-toe with an elite amateur wielding a whole set costing less than a new driver in today's market?

£500 Bag - Sam De'Ath (+4 Handicap)

£500 bag of clubs from golfclubs4cash

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)
Swipe to scroll horizontally

Club

Model

Price

Driver

Callaway Epic Flash Sub Zero

£127.99

Fairway Wood

TaylorMade RBZ Tour

£52.99

Hybrid

Adams Idea Pro a12

£39.99

Irons

Mizuno MP-68 (4-PW)

£119.99

Wedges

Cleveland RTX4 (60°)

£31.19

Putter

Odyssey Stroke Lab #7

£118.99

When tasked with building my whole golf bag for just £500, I was genuinely a little concerned. But after five minutes scouring the golfclubs4cash website, it was clear there were some absolute gems to be snagged at an incredible price.

The Callaway Epic Flash Sub Zero kicked things off for me at the top of the bag. Compact behind the ball, designed for low spin and plenty of hosel adjustment. Driving is a strength of my game, and this driver didn’t compromise me at all.

The TaylorMade RBZ Tour fairway wood was known for its blistering ball speed and impressive distance back when it launched, and it’s safe to say for £53 it didn’t disappoint. On the 3rd tee, I turned to this club, moving the ball a little right-to-left, sending the ball a long way down and on the short grass.

Sam De'Ath hitting a driver

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

The Mizuno MP-68 irons were a real treat to put in the bag, and despite being 17 years old, they felt like butter off the face. They were a little intimidating in the longer irons due to the bladed profile, but I couldn’t resist adding these to my setup for just £119. Another highlight was the Odyssey Stroke Lab #7 putter, which is a shape I love, was easy to roll, and had the bonus of a Reverse Taper Golf Pride grip attached.

Because of a higher investment throughout the rest of the bag, I was short on cash when it came to the wedges. In fact, I could only afford one. A Cleveland RTX4 60° with just 4 degrees of bounce. This proved to be costly on the tight, soft turf at Berkhamsted GC and resulted in a few chip shots travelling no further than a couple of feet! But all in all, I was happy with my 9-hole total.

Final score: +1

£1,000 Bag - Joel Tadman (3 Handicap)

Joel Tadman clubs

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)
Swipe to scroll horizontally

Club

Model

Price

Driver

Titleist TSi3

£200

Fairway Wood

TaylorMade M1

£128

Irons

Ping iBlades

£300

Wedges

Titleist Vokey SM8 (50°), Cleveland RTX Full Face (56°)

£155

Putter

Odyssey Ai One Dual 1/2 Ball DW

£204

When choosing the clubs for my £1,000 bag from golfclubs4cash, I was surprised at how many I was able to add while still being on budget! I remember fondly my time using the TSi3 driver at the time of its release, the same can be said for the Ping iBlades.

However, my lack of familiarity with the clubs, as well as a drop in forgiveness versus what I currently use, showed up very early on. I came up 20 yards short of the 2nd green (resulting in an ugly double bogey) before missing the 3rd fairway 30 yards right. This was mostly down to user error, it must be said, and I steadied the ship towards the end of the round.

One of the big mistakes I made was not adding a high-lofted fairway wood as a reliable fairway finder off the tee. Berkhamsted is not a long course, yet I was left without a club I could trust to find the short grass from the tee. In hindsight, I should have opted for a 4-PW iron set and added a 7-wood - and golfclubs4cash has loads I could have chosen!

Joel Tadman clubs

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

In terms of highlights, I really enjoyed the throwback look and feel of the Ping iBlades. Soft but with a hint of spring to them, solid strikes were rewarded with predictable distances - an example being when I hit my second shot on the third to 8-foot pin high right.

I enjoyed the putter too - despite grazing the edge on multiple occasions, I’m beginning to come around to the idea that modern-day alignment cues and off-center forgiveness can actually make a difference on the greens.

Final score: +6

£2000 Bag - Johnny Percival (8 Handicap)

£2000 bag of clubs from golfclubs4cash

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)
Swipe to scroll horizontally

Club

Model

Price

Driver

TaylorMade Qi10

£300

Fairway Wood

TaylorMade Qi35 (18°)

£279

Irons

Titleist U510 4-iron, Callaway Ai 200 (5-AW)

£900

Wedges

Ping S159 (52°, 54° and 58°)

£250

Putter

Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2

£270

With £2,000 to play with, the options were nearly endless at golfclubs4cash, and I was shopping for clubs that were only two, sometimes even one season old. Starting with the big stick, the TaylorMade Qi10 was hard to ignore, a stalwart in the bags of both Rory McIlroy and Scottie Scheffler. On the day, I hit some really solid drives, but the narrow nature of the course did catch me out on a few occasions.

Sticking with TaylorMade in the 5-wood was again a smart choice, the Qi35 offered plenty of forgiveness and versatility at the top end. I mixed things up with my irons, opting for a Titleist U510 in the 4-iron.

The larger head offers that extra bit of forgiveness, and the hollow design packs a real punch, especially off the tee. In the irons, the Callaway Ai 200s were an easy pickup, and wedge-wise, Ping’s S159s were another really solid option.

golfer putting

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

While I was generally really happy with the performance of all of my clubs, the one mistake I did make was with my putter. I opted for a beautiful Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2, and while it looked great in the bag, I really should have gone for a larger mallet design that offered more forgiveness.

My putting on the day was pretty woeful, and had I stuck with a mallet design closer to my usual gamer, I think a few more putts would have dropped. All in all, it's fair to say you get plenty of bang for your buck with £2,000, and I could have gone in so many different directions with my equipment. Sadly, my game wasn’t able to keep up with my equipment on the day.

Final score: +8

The Verdict

Three golfers walking along a fairway

(Image credit: Howard Boylan)

Our key takeaways from this experiment are firstly that ability conquers all - good players are capable of shooting good scores with older equipment not fully tailored to their swing. There are bargains to be had as a result, especially if you’re partial to a trip down memory lane, from the golfclubs4cash website.

The added playability of new clubs can help if your game is slightly off, and many will see distance gains, but it can’t perform miracles. If you build your bag wisely, configuring it with old types of clubs you are comfortable using or that suit the courses you play, you can enjoy your golf on a modest budget.

Joel Tadman
Deputy Editor

Joel has worked in the golf industry for over 15 years covering both instruction and more recently equipment. He now oversees all equipment and video content at Golf Monthly, managing a team of talented and passionate writers and presenters in delivering the most thorough and accurate reviews, buying advice, comparisons and deals to help the reader or viewer find exactly what they are looking for.

He currently plays his golf at Burghley Park Golf Club in Stamford, Lincs, with a handicap index of 2.9.

Joel's current What's In The Bag?

Driver: TaylorMade Qi4D, 10°, Fujikura Ventus VeloCore+ Blue 6 S shaft.
Fairway woods: TaylorMade Qi4D, 15° and 21°.
Irons: Titleist T150, 4-PW
Wedges: Titleist Vokey SM11, 49°, 54° and 59°
Putter: L.A.B. Golf DF3
Ball: 2026 TaylorMade TP5x Stripe